Are NYC Co-ops More Affordable Compared to Condos?  

Share On

Yes. NYC co-ops tend to be cheaper than and more affordable than condos on average. According to the Q3 reports, the average sale price of condos was 67% higher than co-ops in Brooklyn and 51% higher in Manhattan. But why are co-ops so much cheaper than condos?

Why are NYC Co-ops Cheaper Than Condos

Several factors derive the difference, including:

  • Fewer Restrictions: Condos are easier to buy, and there are usually no subletting or rental restrictions. This makes them easier for a larger pool of buyers, including investors. However, more competition and desirability drive up the cost, making condos more expensive than co-ops. 
  • Building Age: Most condo buildings are relatively newer constructions. We used the comparable data from the co-op and condo provided by the NYC government to compare the average “Age” of the available listings. It’s about 98 years for co-ops and 61 years for condo buildings. Since co-ops have more stock of older units in the market compared to condos, they usually command a lower price.
  • Price Appreciation: Historically, co-op prices have appreciated slower (about 4% per annum) compared to condos (6% per annum), which can accumulate to a significant difference.
  • Size: In the same category (studio, one-bedroom, etc.), co-ops are, on average, smaller than condos. This shrinks the per-square-foot price difference but makes co-ops significantly cheaper (on average) than condos.
  • Amenities: Condos often offer a wider range of amenities than co-ops, which adds to the price.
Historic co-op apartment buildings with fire escapes in New York City, showcasing classic architecture and affordable housing options

Thanks to this price difference, co-ops are naturally far more desirable than condos in NYC. In most quarters, a much higher percentage of co-ops are listed close to condos. 

It’s essential to understand that the price is just one variable. You should have an experienced New York City Broker by your side to ensure that you are getting the best property for the amount you are spending and not just a discounted price. 

Also Read: 3 Disadvantages of Co-op Living


Follow Us

The Latest

BROWSE ARTICLES

You May Also Like

Learn how long it takes to sell an apartment in NYC, from listing to closing. Factors include co-op boards, market dynamics, and buyer financing. Consult a New York City broker.

NYC Apartment Selling Timeline

How long does it take to sell an apartment in New York? That depends on a number of factors, including the market dynamics and the type of apartment you are selling. In some markets, buyers are trying to close as early as possible, while in others, apartments may sit on the apartment for several weeks before finding the right buyer.

A row of historic brownstone buildings in NYC, highlighting tax considerations for co-op sellers.

4 Taxes Co-op NYC Sellers Need to Know About

Before you sell your co-op apartment, it’s important to know the answer to this question – What are the taxes on the sale of a NYC co-op? There are four taxes all co-op owners should know about.

A magnifying glass over financial charts with real estate data, symbolizing NYC market predictions for 2025.

NYC Real Estate Market Prediction For 2025

Buyers and sellers alike are asking their peers and New York City brokers, “What is the market prediction for 2025?” Accurate predictions can help them make more informed decisions. Multiple brokers and experts generally predict that there might be many buyers in the market, albeit without a comparable number of sellers. So, the market, in general, will lean more towards sellers.

A view of the New York City skyline showcasing modern and historic buildings, representing the 2025 real estate market trends.

New York Real Estate Outlook For 2025

What is the NYC real estate outlook for 2025? Buyers, sellers, landlords, tenants, and even investors might have this question. The outlook doesn’t look really good for corporate investors since the introduction of good cause eviction does put limits on rent increases, even for market-rate apartments. A few predictions that may define the real estate outlook for 2025 for different stakeholders are

A 3D illustration of a house with a yellow roof on a light blue background, with bold text stating 'Time to Sell Your HOME,' representing the decision to sell a property in NYC.

Is It The Right Time To Sell Your House in NYC?

The average price has risen modestly between Q3 and Q4 in both Brooklyn and Manhattan. Assuming that this growth trend has continued into the new year, it might be a good time to sell in both these boroughs. However, co-ops didn’t perform as well in Brooklyn and the average price fell for almost all categories in Queens.

A staged home with a ‘Time to Sell Your Home’ graphic, symbolizing home preparation for the market.

Getting Your Home Ready To Sell in New York 

Based on what you are selling (property type) and in what kind of market (buyer’s or seller’s), the amount of time and effort you need to make your NYC home ready to sell may vary drastically. Many buyers may propose buying the property as-is in the seller’s market. But in the buyer’s market, you may have to make the property more appealing.

Tall residential buildings under a blue sky, representing the cost per square foot of Manhattan apartments.

Average Price Per Square Foot For A Manhattan Apartment 

If you are planning on buying an apartment in the borough, one question you might have is – What is the average price per square foot for an apartment in Manhattan? The exact answer to this varies from time to time and based on the type of apartment you want to buy, but one consistent fact is that it’s almost always higher than the other four boroughs.