Buying an Apartment in New York – Should You Get A Broker or Go Solo? 

Share On

Do you need a broker to buy an apartment in NYC? Legally, no. You are perfectly within your rights to look for, negotiate, and close an apartment on your own. However, whether it’s smarter to work with a New York City broker or do it on your own is a different question. 

New York City Broker – Yay or Nay?

As a buyer, there is relatively little incentive to not work with a broker. The commission is paid by the seller, and even if you don’t get a broker, they will end up paying the full commission to their broker/listing agent. Theoretically, this may give them an edge because if a listing agent doesn’t have to split commission with a buyer’s agent, they get to keep all six percent. This might be incentive enough for them to push their seller towards a buyer that’s in the market without a broker.

Now let’s take a look at the reasons to have a broker when you are buying an apartment in NYC:

  • Since many NYC properties are in exclusive listings that only brokers have access to, you may have fewer options if you go without a broker. 
  • They offer extensive market knowledge and experience and can help you find the perfect fit for your budget.
  • They can negotiate on your behalf to get a better price and get the property fixed.
  • A broker may help you identify weaknesses or strengths in an apartment that you may not uncover yourself, allowing you to make a more informed decision.
  • When you are buying a co-op apartment, an experienced New York City broker (ideally someone who has worked with the same building previously) can significantly increase your chances of closing the purchase. They can guide you on the board package and even prepare you for a board interview.

So, do you need a broker to buy an apartment in NYC? Technically, no, but it can significantly improve the process and increase your chances of buying the best apartment in your budget. 
Also read: What Is A Managing Agent?


Follow Us

The Latest

BROWSE ARTICLES

You May Also Like

Scrabble tiles arranged to spell 'MORTGAGE' surrounded by scattered letters on a wooden surface

Analyzing The Current Mortgage Rate in NYC 

The mortgage rates in NYC (at the time of writing this) are hovering between 6.25% and 6.8% for 30-year fixed-rate mortgages. However, the answer is, what is today’s mortgage rate in NYC? Keeps on changing, often daily. So, the best place to get this answer is local, NYC-based sources or other aggregate sources that offer this information for multiple cities. 

Photo of NYC's Upper East Side, one of the neighborhoods preferred by millionaires.

4 NYC Neighborhoods Preferred By Millionaires 

Over 69% of the condos in Manhattan closed for more than $1 million in October 2024. So, in a way, most millionaire condo owners are technically millionaires and are spread out over the city. But if you set a higher bar (multi-millionaires) and wonder where do the millionaires live in NYC? we can narrow down the selections. It’s worth noting that New York has one of the highest concentrations of millionaires in the world, with about 349,500 millionaires (one in every 24 people in the city), and 744 of them are cent millionaires, with a net worth of over $100 million.

Graphical representation of NYC property price trends showing fluctuations in co-op and condo markets.

NYC Property Prices – Up or Down? 

Are NYC real estate prices dropping? Many potential buyers repeatedly ask this question to find the best time to enter the market. As per the NYC Comptroller report, median home values in the city were falling at the beginning of the year. However, if we look at the “All-Transactions House Price Index for New York,” it has risen for both the first and second quarter of 2024, and the upward momentum is not waning, which indicates that the prices are still going up. However, another report suggests that the median asking price has remained steady between April and September (at $1,1 million).

Skyline of Manhattan neighborhoods, showcasing prime locations for living in New York City.

How To Find The Best Place To Live in Manhattan? 

If you ask your New York City broker, “Where is the most desirable place to live in Manhattan?” they would ask a few questions to narrow down the neighborhood most desirable for you. These questions would start from your budget – how much rent or mortgage you can afford, what type of property and space you want, etc. However, several other factors apply to almost everyone who lives and wants to live in Manhattan, like green spaces, the environment, activities, easy commute, etc.

Visual of steps to get approved for an apartment in NYC.,

Getting Approved For An Apartment in NYC – How Hard Is It?

Getting approved as a buyer is mainly a co-op problem. If you are buying a condo, the board does have some power to reject you through the “right of first refusal,” but this rarely happens. However, the co-op board approval process can be quite hard when buying a co-op apartment. You need stellar financials, a solid application, a good board interview, and multiple reference letters. Even then, it’s usually a good idea to work with a New York City broker who works with that co-op and knows the board’s process and preferences to make approval easier. 

Panoramic view of a New York City neighborhood highlighting diverse architecture and urban planning.

Finding The Most Desirable Neighborhood in New York 

If you want to buy a home in the city, it’s natural to ask, “What is the most desirable neighborhood in New York?” But the answer is not as straightforward as you might think. Desirability can be highly subjective, and what’s most desirable to some may not be as desirable to others. There are also no formal rankings for neighborhoods in NYC that we can leverage to identify the most desirable neighborhood. We looked into several lists, and Greenwich Village (in Manhattan) was either at the top or in the top five of most of them. 

Couple discussing real estate trends with a broker in preparation to buy a house in NYC.

Buying A House in NYC in 2025 – What To Expect

Whether you are a New Yorker already renting and planning to buy a home or someone moving into the city, it might benefit you to understand the housing market trends. There are a lot of things you should know about, starting with a crucial question – will 2025 be a better time to buy a house? An overarching answer to this question is that it would be better in some ways and worse in others.

Checklist and paperwork required for purchasing an apartment in New York City."

A List of Everything You Need To Buy An Apartment in NYC

What does it take to buy an apartment in NYC? The simplest answer is enough money and a good New York City broker. However, a decision as important as buying an apartment in NYC is rarely as simple.