Share On

Is it wise to buy real estate in NYC? This is a question most prospective homeowners in the city have, thanks to the sky-high property prices. The answer is not a simple yes or no and is influenced by a number of factors. 

The first factor to consider is why you are buying an NYC property in the first place. If you want to move away from renting, then it’s almost always a smart move. If you want to put down roots in the city and have a job or business that will likely remain here for the next five, ten, or more years, then it’s a good idea to buy a property in NYC. 

These factors supersede the property’s worth and potential as an investment. However, if you need to analyze this query from an investment perspective, there are two different paths. For people who are buying a property in NYC to live in, mostly focus on its price appreciation. 

Here, the location and type of your property will play an important role. Average property prices in most Manhattan neighborhoods rose by over 100% between 2010 and 2020, going as high as 160% for Harlem. That’s an annualized growth of at least 10%. 

Median property prices in Brooklyn rose by about half of that between 2015 and 2024. There was a significant difference among property types as well. The average price per square foot in Manhattan rose by about 16% for one-bedroom apartments and actually fell by over 5% for 4-bedrooms between 2015 and 2023. Market conditions play a critical role in price appreciation trends. 

An infographic or chart analyzing the pros and cons of investing in NYC real estate, with key factors such as market trends, property values, rental income potential, and long-term investment outlook.

The same level of variation can be seen if you assess the properties purely from a rental yield perspective. But it’s worth noting that cap rates for most NYC properties are consistently low. But if you combine rent-based returns with price appreciation, it’s easy to see that real estate in NYC is typically a smart purchase. 

Read more: Own Apartment in NYC

Follow Us

The Latest

BROWSE ARTICLES

You May Also Like

A financial advisor reviewing data and interest rates, representing expert guidance on finding the best mortgage rates in NYC.

Looking for The Best Mortgage Rate? What You Should Know

Who typically has the best mortgage rates? This is the question most potential homebuyers ask, regardless of whether they are in NYC or any other city. Based on the latest rates for New York, the lowest mortgage rates are offered by Farmers Bank of Kansas City. However, lower doesn’t always mean the best.

A financial decision-making concept showing a professional analyzing banking options for the best mortgage rates in NYC

Choosing The Best Bank To Get A Mortgage in NYC 

What is the best bank to get a mortgage? The answer depends upon several factors, and where you are buying is one of them. NYC is home to some of the largest banks in the world, and potential buyers may have more options to choose from here. However, too many choices can make the process of choosing the best difficult.

Buying an Apartment in New York – Should You Get A Broker or Go Solo? 

Do you need a broker to buy an apartment in NYC? Legally, no. You are perfectly within your rights to look for, negotiate, and close an apartment on your own. However, whether it’s smarter to work with a New York City broker or do it on your own is a different question. 

Scrabble tiles arranged to spell 'MORTGAGE' surrounded by scattered letters on a wooden surface

Analyzing The Current Mortgage Rate in NYC 

The mortgage rates in NYC (at the time of writing this) are hovering between 6.25% and 6.8% for 30-year fixed-rate mortgages. However, the answer is, what is today’s mortgage rate in NYC? Keeps on changing, often daily. So, the best place to get this answer is local, NYC-based sources or other aggregate sources that offer this information for multiple cities. 

Photo of NYC's Upper East Side, one of the neighborhoods preferred by millionaires.

4 NYC Neighborhoods Preferred By Millionaires 

Over 69% of the condos in Manhattan closed for more than $1 million in October 2024. So, in a way, most millionaire condo owners are technically millionaires and are spread out over the city. But if you set a higher bar (multi-millionaires) and wonder where do the millionaires live in NYC? we can narrow down the selections. It’s worth noting that New York has one of the highest concentrations of millionaires in the world, with about 349,500 millionaires (one in every 24 people in the city), and 744 of them are cent millionaires, with a net worth of over $100 million.

Graphical representation of NYC property price trends showing fluctuations in co-op and condo markets.

NYC Property Prices – Up or Down? 

Are NYC real estate prices dropping? Many potential buyers repeatedly ask this question to find the best time to enter the market. As per the NYC Comptroller report, median home values in the city were falling at the beginning of the year. However, if we look at the “All-Transactions House Price Index for New York,” it has risen for both the first and second quarter of 2024, and the upward momentum is not waning, which indicates that the prices are still going up. However, another report suggests that the median asking price has remained steady between April and September (at $1,1 million).

Skyline of Manhattan neighborhoods, showcasing prime locations for living in New York City.

How To Find The Best Place To Live in Manhattan? 

If you ask your New York City broker, “Where is the most desirable place to live in Manhattan?” they would ask a few questions to narrow down the neighborhood most desirable for you. These questions would start from your budget – how much rent or mortgage you can afford, what type of property and space you want, etc. However, several other factors apply to almost everyone who lives and wants to live in Manhattan, like green spaces, the environment, activities, easy commute, etc.

Visual of steps to get approved for an apartment in NYC.,

Getting Approved For An Apartment in NYC – How Hard Is It?

Getting approved as a buyer is mainly a co-op problem. If you are buying a condo, the board does have some power to reject you through the “right of first refusal,” but this rarely happens. However, the co-op board approval process can be quite hard when buying a co-op apartment. You need stellar financials, a solid application, a good board interview, and multiple reference letters. Even then, it’s usually a good idea to work with a New York City broker who works with that co-op and knows the board’s process and preferences to make approval easier.